Contact Us:

(419) 573-6473

Get In Touch

CATAWBA ISLAND'S HOMETOWN JEWELER

Timeless Treasures, Trusted Expertise

Welcome to Catawba Island Jewelers, the premier destination jeweler for the Lake Erie Shores & Islands. From the perfect engagement ring for your Lakeside Marblehead proposal to a custom design that captures your unique spirit, our passion is bringing your vision to life. We combine decades of expertise with the warmth and integrity you deserve, making us the trusted choice for fine jewelry in Port Clinton and beyond.

A modern men's wedding band in brushed yellow gold, featuring a tension-set radiant cut diamond, from the custom design collection at Catawba Island Jewelers in Port Clinton, Ohio.
Spectacular 3.85-carat oval diamond engagement ring with half-moon side stones, set in platinum, an example of the high-quality custom bridal jewelry from Catawba Island Jewelers in Port Clinton, Ohio.
A men's brushed sterling silver wedding band with an engraved anchor and rope design, part of the nautical jewelry collection available at Catawba Island Jewelers in Port Clinton, Ohio.
Explore Our Collections

YOUR FOREVER BEGINS HERE

The Perfect Ring for Your Unforgettable Moment

From the joyful 'yes' to the vows you'll cherish forever, your journey deserves a symbol as unique as your love story. At Catawba Island Jewelers, expert diamond selection is a truly personal experience. You will be guided directly by our owner and Certified Diamontologist, Kristie Pooley, who provides the dedicated attention and integrity you deserve as you find or custom-design the ring that perfectly captures your vision. Trust us to be a part of your forever.

0 +

Years of Combined Experience

0 +

Happy Couples Served

Begin Your Journey
A woman's hand showing off a stunning floral-style diamond engagement ring, holding a celebratory mug, from the bridal collection at Catawba Island Jewelers in Port Clinton, Ohio.

OUR SERVICES

A Commitment to Craftsmanship & Quality

We believe that true luxury lies in the details. From expert on-site repairs to breathtaking custom designs and a world-class selection of diamonds, our mission is to provide an unparalleled level of service. As your trusted destination jeweler for the Lakeside Marblehead area, every aspect of our business is built on a foundation of expertise, integrity, and a passion for excellence.

Expert Watch Repair & Services

From a simple battery replacement to a complex movement repair, your timepiece is in trusted hands. We offer professional, on-site service for most watch brands, including Seiko, right here in our workshop.

Master Craftsmanship

From intricate diamond setting to restoration of a family heirloom, your most treasured pieces are in the hands of an expert. Our master bench jeweler, Carlo, performs all work in our workshop, ensuring the highest level of quality control.

An Unmatched Selection

At Catawba Island Jewelers, we are a member of the Retail Jewelers Organization (RJO), an invitation-only group of the nation's top independent jewelers. Membership is a testament to our high reputation. 

You Get More Services

Explore Now
Kristie Pooley, the Diamontologist and owner of Catawba Island Jewelers, a trusted local jewelry store in Port Clinton, Ohio.

VISIT OUR SHOWROOM

Meet the Expert Behind the Craft

My name is Kristie Pooley, and I bring you over 25+ years of "hands on" experience in the jewelry industry. I am a Certified Diamontologist, and have attended GIA Diamond Grading School as well as hold a certificate with GIA in Jewelry Display. 

Meet Kristie

Hours of Operation

Tuesday-Friday

11AM - 6PM

Saturday

11AM - 4PM

Sunday-Monday

Closed

Call Us Today:

(419) 573-6473

OUR REVIEWS

Trusted by Our Community. Proven by Our 5-Star Reviews.

We are incredibly proud of our perfect 5-star rating on Google. These are more than just reviews; they are stories from our wonderful clients who have become part of our family. They reflect our deep commitment to providing a truly personal, one-on-one experience guided by an expert. We believe trust is earned, one happy client at a time, and we are honored to be the trusted destination jeweler for Lakeside Marblehead and our visitors from across Ohio.

Crystal

Kristie helped us find the most perfect ring. She ensured it was authentic and wonderful quality. Once it was made, she ensured it was shipped quickly to a local jeweler to receive and verify. When my boyfriend proposed I was completely caught off guard and forgot how stunning the ring was. I am looking forward to wearing this beautiful ring for the rest of my life!

Tori, a happy client from Toledo, Ohio, providing a glowing testimonial for the personal service and custom jewelry design at Catawba Island Jewelers.

Tori

Kristie is truly the best! My engagement ring and our wedding bands were all through Catawba Island Jewelers. I can be particular and Kristie made sure I was 100% satisfied! Excellent communication. So happy with our purchases and would recommend them for all your jewelry needs!

Lacey

I had a very swollen finger and my ring was cutting off my circulation. After many attempts to get the ring off myself, I called Catawba Island Jewelers. I went in right away and she used a ring cutter to get it off. She was very gentle and there was very little discomfort. She was so nice and helpful during a time of stress of not knowing what else to do. Great job Kristie!

OUR REVIEWS

Visit Our Showroom

The true beauty of a piece is best experienced in person. We invite you to our beautiful showroom, a trusted jewelry destination for the entire Lake Erie Shores & Islands. Whether you're traveling from Perrysburg or Cleveland, we look forward to to providing the personal, one-on-one guidance you deserve. Come see for yourself why our clients give us a perfect 5-star rating.

The official logo for Dune Jewelry & Co., a unique brand of experiential jewelry available at Catawba Island Jewelers, the premier retailer in Lakeside Marblehead, Ohio.
The official logo for Luminar Creations, a designer of fine bridal and lab-grown diamond engagement rings, available exclusively in Port Clinton, Ohio at Catawba Island Jewelers.
The official logo for Ostbye, a trusted designer of fine engagement rings and wedding bands for over 100 years, available at Catawba Island Jewelers in Port Clinton, Ohio.
Alt Text: The official logo for Quality Gold, a complete jewelry source and trusted partner of Catawba Island Jewelers in Port Clinton, Ohio.
The official logo for Seiko watches, a world-renowned brand of precision timepieces, available at Catawba Island Jewelers, an authorized dealer in Port Clinton, Ohio.
Powered by Stuller. Our partnership gives you access to a world-class selection of diamonds, gemstones, and settings for your perfect custom piece.
The official logo for 4ocean, a global ocean cleanup company, proudly partnered with Catawba Island Jewelers in Port Clinton to support the clean ocean movement.
Favicon for Catawba Island Jewelers, the premier destination jeweler for Port Clinton and Lakeside Marblehead.

Your Engagement Ring Headquarters

Proudly serving Catawba Island, Lakeside Marblehead, Port Clinton, and the greater Toledo, Cleveland, and Columbus communities.

Facebook Google Instagram Yelp

Hours

Tuesday-Friday

11AM - 6PM

Saturday

11AM - 4PM

Sunday-Monday

Closed

Call Us Today:

(419) 573-6473

Copyright © 2025 Catawba Island Jewelers. All Rights Reserved.

Powered by
►
Necessary cookies enable essential site features like secure log-ins and consent preference adjustments. They do not store personal data.
None
►
Functional cookies support features like content sharing on social media, collecting feedback, and enabling third-party tools.
None
►
Analytical cookies track visitor interactions, providing insights on metrics like visitor count, bounce rate, and traffic sources.
None
►
Advertisement cookies deliver personalized ads based on your previous visits and analyze the effectiveness of ad campaigns.
None
Powered by